Apartment tried to evict woman; HUD said it broke the law
Woman Wins $165K after Facing Eviction over Emotional Support Parrots
A New York woman is set to be paid $165,000 in damages plus $585,000 for her apartment after the building attempted to evict her because of her three emotional support parrots.
Meril Lesser moved into the Rutherford, a 175-unit cooperative apartment building, in 1999. She lived there with the birds, which the Department of Justice said were to assist with her disabilities, without incident until March 2015. That’s when one of her neighbors started to complain about the alleged noise coming from Lesser’s apartment.
Over the course of a year, the New York City Department of Environmental Protection visited the building and Lesser’s apartment 15 times to conduct inspections. The DEP issues zero violations in any of those instances, with one inspector writing “no birds, no screeching — no noise,” on Feb. 7, 2016, The New York Post reported.
Rutherford did not conduct any evaluation over the noise themselves, and did not hire anyone with experience in soundproofing to address the neighbor’s complaints either, the DOJ said.
In March 2016, Lesser asked Rutherford to let her keep the parrots and gave them a letter from her psychiatrist. Despite this, the DOJ said, the apartment building began eviction proceedings against her in May 2016, causing Lesser “severe emotional harm.” Lesser left the apartment in July of that year, but Rutherford continued to maintain the eviction proceeding “well into 2024,” the Justice Department said.
Need Legal Help?
Chat with a real estate lawyer near you. It’s only $5 for a 1-week trial. Ask unlimited questions.
Lesser filed a complaint with the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development in May 2018, saying the eviction proceeding interfered with her fair housing rights. Under federal law, reasonable accommodations in “rules, policies, practices, and services” must be provided to afford equal housing opportunities to those with disabilities. The Federal Housing Administration allows people with disabilities to use a wide array of animals as support pets, as long as they do not pose a direct threat to others’ safety or health, and don’t damage the property.
Accessibility