A guarantor agrees to cover the rent if a tenant fails to pay

Print Friendly

Renting property always carries some level of risk. Even tenants who appear financially stable and responsible can present challenges when it comes to paying rent on time. This is where a guarantor can make a big difference.

A guarantor agrees to cover the rent if a tenant fails to pay. Unlike a cosigner, who shares full legal and financial responsibility from the start of the lease, a guarantor acts as a backup. For landlords, this provides an additional layer of security when there’s uncertainty about a tenant’s ability to meet their obligations.

Understanding What a Guarantor Does

A guarantor functions much like a safety net. They rarely need to step in, but knowing they are available if a tenant defaults gives landlords peace of mind. Guarantors are becoming more common in today’s rental market, especially for younger tenants, college students, or applicants with limited credit or rental history.

For example, a college student renting their first apartment may not have a strong credit score or consistent employment history, if any. Having a parent as a guarantor ensures that the landlord has someone financially responsible to fall back on in case of missed payments.

Professional tenant screening services, like AAOA, can complement a guarantor by providing in-depth credit, eviction, and background data. This allows landlords to make well-informed decisions rather than relying solely on instinct or trust.

How Guarantors Differ From Cosigners

While both guarantors and cosigners provide financial backing, their roles are distinct:

• A cosigner shares full responsibility from the beginning of the lease and may also reside in the unit.
• A guarantor is only responsible if the tenant defaults and usually does not occupy the rental unit.

This distinction is important for landlords to understand so they can set appropriate expectations. Both typically undergo rental credit checks and background checks to ensure they are financially capable. Regardless of who is financially backing the lease, always know who will live in your property. Asking clear questions on your rental application protects your investment and helps avoid misunderstandings.

When a Guarantor Is Recommended

Landlords typically request guarantors when applicants have financial or rental histories that suggest some risk. This might include:

• Limited or no credit history
• Past financial difficulties or high debt
• Inconsistent or irregular income
• Student status or first-time renters

Additionally, a guarantor may be needed if the tenant has weak references, prior missed rent payments, or a history of evictions. Every rental application should be evaluated individually, considering both the tenant’s current situation and their overall ability to meet lease obligations.

For example, a recent college graduate may have a steady job but minimal or no credit history. A guarantor can provide reassurance that rent payments will be covered while the tenant builds their own financial track record. Similarly, someone who recently changed jobs or works part-time may need a guarantor until their income stabilizes.

Checking Local Laws

Before requiring a guarantor, it’s essential to understand local regulations. Some states and cities have restrictions on when landlords can request a guarantor. For example, in New York City, landlords cannot require a guarantor for tenants using housing vouchers solely based on income. Failing to comply with local laws could result in fines or legal challenges, so consulting qualified legal counsel is always recommended.

How Screening Reports Help Landlords Decide

Professional tenant screening is a cornerstone of safe, responsible leasing. Services like AAOA provide detailed reports that include:

• Financial responsibility: Credit reports help predict whether a tenant is likely to pay rent on time.
• Employment Verification: Employment Verification confirms whether an applicant actually works at the business they reported on their application.
• Eviction and criminal history: Reports reveal prior evictions or relevant criminal records, helping landlords assess potential risk.

Screening reports complement the use of a guarantor. They provide objective data to determine if a tenant can pay independently or if a guarantor is a necessary safeguard.

Benefits of Having a Guarantor

Requiring a guarantor offers several advantages for landlords:

• Reduced financial risk: A backup payer helps ensure rent is covered even if the tenant defaults.
• Peace of mind: Knowing there is someone financially responsible gives landlords confidence.
• Encourages tenant responsibility: Tenants are more likely to pay on time when a family member or close associate is financially backing them.

For example, when a parent acts as a guarantor, tenants often feel accountable, not just to the landlord but also to their guarantor, encouraging timely rent payments and better communication.

Potential Drawbacks

While a guarantor provides security, it’s not foolproof. There are some considerations. A guarantor may still fail to cover rent if the tenant defaults. Landlords must screen the guarantor, communicate with multiple parties, and maintain extra documentation.

Despite these drawbacks, many landlords find that the benefits outweigh the extra effort, particularly when dealing with applicants whose financial history is uncertain.

Simplifying rent collection can further reduce missed payments. Online payment systems provide automated reminders and make record keeping easier for both landlords and tenants.

Lease Guarantee: When a Guarantor is Not Available

Not every qualified applicant has someone willing or able to co-sign a lease. When that happens, landlords face added risk if the tenant leaves behind unpaid rent or costly damage that exceeds the security deposit. Even taking the tenant to court rarely results in full repayment, since many renters don’t have the assets to satisfy a judgment, and hiring a collection agency often adds expense without improving the outcome.

LeaseGuarantee fills that gap by acting as a financial safety net when no guarantor is available. Instead of pursuing former tenants, you receive reimbursement for covered losses up to your LeaseGuarantee protection amount. Protection amounts range from $1,000 to $10,000 and can reimburse for missed rent, damages, and certain legal fees.

Most AAOA tenant screening packages include a free LeaseGuarantee Analyzer. LeaseGuarantee starts as low as $199 per year for $1,000 of protection with options up to $10,000 of protection and can be purchased by you or the applicant.

LeaseGuarantee includes all individuals on the lease agreement for 12 months and is renewable. With LeaseGuarantee as your protection, you can reduce or eliminate the deposit or need for a cosigner.

Making Confident Decisions

Red flags on a rental application do not automatically mean rejection. Combining tenant screening with a guarantor or LeaseGuarantee can provide a balanced approach. Services like AAOA give landlords insights into credit, income, eviction history, and criminal records, making it easier to decide whether a guarantor is needed or if the tenant can manage independently.

For instance, a tenant with a solid income but limited rental history may still be approved if a guarantor is in place. Conversely, a tenant with strong credit and rental experience may not need additional backing. By using data alongside common sense, landlords can reduce risk while filling their rental units efficiently.

Lease guarantors are a valuable tool for landlords navigating uncertain tenant situations. They act as a financial safety net, providing peace of mind and reducing risk, especially for applicants with limited credit, irregular income, or minimal rental history. By combining careful tenant screening with the strategic use of guarantors, landlords can make informed decisions, protect their investments, and maintain steady rental income.

If you need assistance with tenant screening or have questions about the rental process, consider reaching out to professionals who specialize in this area. AAOA offers a variety of services, including insurance, rent reporting, rent collection and financing. 

Contact us today to learn more.

Disclaimer: Nothing contained on this website constitutes tax, legal, insurance or investment advice, nor does it constitute a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. AAOA recommends you consult with a financial advisor, tax specialist, attorney or other specialist who is able to properly advise you.