Define the qualities of a dependable tenant for your property
Identify Problem Tenants Before They Move In
A small amount of preparation early can help landlords avoid late payments, excessive complaints, property damage, and other issues that often stem from rushed or inconsistent tenant selection.
Identifying problem renters before they move in begins with a clear, consistent tenant screening process.
Clarifying the Kind of Tenant You Want
Before reviewing rental applications, define the qualities of a dependable tenant for your property. Establishing objective criteria helps ensure that your tenant screening process remains consistent and fair across all applicants.
Common qualities many landlords look for include:
- Steady income that supports the monthly rent
- Respectful and timely communication
- No history of evictions
- A positive background check
It is equally important to identify behaviors that may signal a poor fit. Frequent moves, incomplete applications, excessive unresolved debt, or reluctance to verify information can indicate higher risk. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, tenant screening reports can contain errors or outdated information, which makes it important for landlords to review reports carefully rather than relying on automated decisions alone.
All screening decisions must comply with state and local fair housing laws. Every applicant must be evaluated using the same standards, and reasonable accommodations must be provided when required.
Creating a Listing That Attracts the Right Renters
Your rental listing shapes a renter’s first impression and helps filter applicants before the screening process begins. A clear, detailed listing attracts serious renters and sets expectations early.
Include key information such as:
- Property type and general location
- Monthly rent and security deposit
- Number of bedrooms and bathrooms, square footage, and notable features
- Included utilities
- Clear, accurate photos
- Lease terms
- Availability date
- Pet policy
Use inclusive, factual language and avoid anything that could be interpreted as discriminatory. Focus on what the property offers rather than expectations about who should live there.
Screen Your Tenant Today!
Gain peace of mind with AAOA’s credit, criminal, and eviction reports.
Getting Your Listing in Front of Quality Applicants
Once your listing is complete, promote it through multiple channels to increase visibility. A larger applicant pool improves your chances of finding a tenant who meets your screening criteria.
Effective options include:
- Posting a For Rent sign in a visible area
- Listing on major rental websites and local social media groups
- Sharing through neighborhood boards or community apps
Before scheduling showings, make sure the property is clean and presentable. A well maintained space signals professional management. Prompt responses to inquiries are also important, especially in competitive rental markets.
A Three-Part Method for Choosing Tenants with Confidence
A structured tenant screening process helps landlords focus on the factors that matter most while maintaining consistency.
- Confirm the rent fits within the applicant’s budget
Verify that applicants have reliable income from wages, benefits, or subsidies that reasonably cover monthly rent. Many landlords use an income guideline of at least three times the rent, though this varies by market. - Review how the applicant manages financial obligations
A credit report reveals payment patterns. Look for consistent, on-time payments and review any accounts in collection or with repeated late payments. As noted by the National Low Income Housing Coalition (NLIHC), recent changes to eviction record access mean landlords should understand how local laws affect what appears in screening reports. - Speak with professional references
References from former landlords, employers, or other professional contacts can provide valuable insight. Ask about reliability, communication, and how the applicant handled their responsibilities.
Why Careful Tenant Screening Matters
Tenants directly affect rental income, property condition, and overall workload. Taking time to screen applicants carefully reduces avoidable problems and helps landlords choose renters who pay on time and respect lease terms and their property.
According to reporting by The Philadelphia Inquirer, some cities now require landlords to disclose screening criteria or limit blanket exclusions based on credit or eviction history. These changes reinforce the need for transparent, well documented screening practices.
As reported by the NLIHC, several states have expanded eviction record-sealing laws, which can limit what screening information is available to landlords and increase the importance of careful, lawful screening practices.
While no screening process eliminates every risk, consistent tenant screening significantly reduces surprises and protects your rental investment.
Final Thoughts
Clear communication supports effective screening. Applicants should understand expectations from the beginning, and landlords should remain available to answer questions. Because laws and rental markets change, it is important to review screening criteria periodically to stay compliant and effective.
Choosing tenants carefully helps prevent problems before they start, and that begins by identifying problem tenants before they move in.
How AAOA Can Help
If you need assistance with tenant screening or have questions about the rental process, consider reaching out to professionals who specialize in this area. In addition to expert tenant screening, AAOA offers a variety of services, including insurance, rent reporting, rent collection and financing.
Contact us today to learn more.
Disclaimer: All content provided here-in is subject to AAOA’s Terms of Use. Nothing contained on this website constitutes tax, legal, insurance or investment advice, nor does it constitute a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. AAOA recommends you consult with a financial advisor, tax specialist, attorney or other specialist who is able to properly advise you.
Accessibility