Complete Landlord Guide to Tenant Screening
How to Screen Tenants
Last month, I got a call from an investor friend who was about to lose $8,000 because he’d rented to someone who seemed “really nice” but hadn’t actually verified their income. Three months later, he was dealing with an eviction, lost rent, and a trashed unit.
The rental market is tighter than it’s been in years, which means you have more applications to choose from. But here’s what most landlords get wrong: they think more options means easier decisions. Actually, it means you need to be even more systematic about how to screen tenants because the stakes are higher and the costs of mistakes have gone up.
Why Proper Tenant Screening Matters More Than Ever
Before we dive into the how-to, let’s talk numbers. The average eviction costs landlords $3,500-$10,000 when you factor in lost rent, legal fees, and turnover costs. That’s not counting the stress, time, and potential property damage.
But here’s the flip side: landlords who follow a consistent tenant screening process report 40% fewer problem tenants and 60% longer average tenancy periods. Translation? Better cash flow, fewer headaches, and higher property values over time.
The key is treating tenant screening like the business process it is—not a gut-feeling exercise.
Step 1: Set Clear Rental Criteria Before You Start
This is where most landlords mess up. They wait until they’re staring at applications to decide what they’re looking for. By then, it’s too late to be objective.
Set these minimums upfront:
-
Monthly income: 3x the rent (some markets require 2.5x, but I prefer the cushion)
-
Credit score: 650+ for most properties (adjust based on your local market)
-
No recent evictions (past 3 years)
-
No recent bankruptcies (past 2 years)
-
Verifiable employment history
Pro tip: Write these criteria down and post them in your listing. This pre-screens applicants and gives you legal protection if someone claims discrimination.
Example: “Requirements: Verifiable monthly income 3x rent, credit score 650+, no evictions in past 3 years, current employment verification required.”
Step 2: Create a Systematic Application Process
Application Requirements:
-
Completed rental application with emergency contacts
-
Government-issued photo ID
-
Most recent pay stubs (2-3 months)
-
Bank statements (2 months)
-
Previous landlord references (2 years minimum)
-
Employment verification letter or contact info
Application fee: Charge $50-$100 to cover screening costs. This also filters out non-serious applicants. Make sure this is legal in your state—some have caps or restrictions.
Timeline: Give yourself 24-48 hours to review applications. Don’t rush this process, but don’t drag it out either. Good tenants have options.
Screen Your Tenant Today!
Gain peace of mind with AAOA’s credit, criminal, and eviction reports.
Step 3: Verify Income Like Your Profit Depends on It (Because It Does)
Income verification is where landlords get lazy, and it’s expensive. “Looks like a nice person” doesn’t pay rent.
Multiple verification sources:
-
Pay stubs (check for consistency in employer name, dates, amounts)
-
Employment verification call to HR or supervisor
-
Bank statements showing regular deposits
-
Tax returns for self-employed applicants (last 2 years)
Red flags to watch for:
-
Pay stubs that look homemade or have inconsistent formatting
-
Employer phone numbers that go to personal cell phones
-
Bank statements with irregular income patterns
-
Large cash deposits without clear sources
Self-employed applicants: Require tax returns, bank statements, and profit/loss statements. Their income should average 4x rent (not 3x) because it’s less predictable.
Step 4: Run Professional Background and Credit Checks
Don’t rely on tenant-provided credit reports. They’re too easy to fake, and you need the full picture.
Use a professional screening service
What you’re looking for:
-
Credit score and payment history
-
Previous evictions or judgments
-
Criminal background (follow fair housing guidelines)
-
Current debt-to-income ratio
Credit score guidelines:
-
750+: Excellent tenant, minimal risk
-
650-749: Good tenant, verify income carefully
-
600-649: Proceed with caution, may require co-signer
-
Below 600: High risk, usually pass unless exceptional circumstances
Step 5: Contact Previous Landlords (Not Just the Current One)
Here’s an insider secret: always call the landlord before the current one. Why? The current landlord might lie to get rid of a problem tenant.
Questions for previous landlords:
-
Did they pay rent on time consistently?
-
Any property damage beyond normal wear?
-
Did they follow lease terms?
-
Any noise complaints or neighbor issues?
-
Would you rent to them again?
-
Why did they move out?
Red flags in landlord references:
-
Reluctance to give details
-
Overly enthusiastic responses (might be trying to get rid of them)
-
Reports of late payments, even if “only occasionally”
-
Multiple moves in short periods
Step 6: Trust Your Gut, But Verify Everything
After all the paperwork, if something feels off, dig deeper. Good tenants understand thorough screening—they actually appreciate working with professional landlords.
Final verification checklist:
-
Employment verification completed
-
Income meets 3x rent requirement
-
Credit and background check clear
-
Landlord references positive
-
Application details consistent across all documents
-
No red flags in gut check
Decision timeline: Make your decision within 48 hours of completing screening. If you’re saying yes, send a lease. If you’re saying no, send a brief, professional decline notice.
Common Tenant Screening Mistakes That Cost Money
Mistake #1: Skipping steps for applicants you “like.” Your criteria apply to everyone, every time.
Mistake #2: Not charging application fees. You’ll get flooded with non-serious applicants.
Mistake #3: Accepting the first qualified applicant without reviewing all applications. You might miss someone better.
Mistake #4: Making exceptions to your criteria. Slippery slope that leads to problem tenants.
Mistake #5: Rushing the process because you need the income. Empty units cost money, but bad tenants cost more.
Legal Considerations for Fair Housing Compliance
Protected classes you cannot discriminate against:
-
Race, color, religion, national origin
-
Sex, familial status, disability
-
Additional local protected classes (age, sexual orientation, etc.)
What you CAN consider:
-
Income and employment history
-
Credit history and rental history
-
Criminal history (with limitations—check local laws)
-
Ability to fulfill lease obligations
Documentation tip: Keep detailed records of why you accepted or rejected each applicant based on your stated criteria. This protects you if discrimination claims arise.
Investor Takeaway
Effective tenant screening isn’t about finding perfect tenants—they don’t exist. It’s about systematically identifying tenants who will pay rent on time, take care of your property, and follow lease terms. The goal is predictable cash flow and minimal drama.
Remember: every month of bad tenant problems is a month you’re not building wealth. Every good tenant you place is actively contributing to your financial freedom.
source: Multifamily Intelligence
Accessibility