Twenty-two of the top 50 markets are now classified as renter‑friendly

Dallas Shutterstock_2469850765

Only Six Apartment Metros Still Favor Landlords

Realtor.com’s January Rental Report makes clear that the balance of power in the U.S. rental market has shifted decisively toward tenants. According to the report, the average rental vacancy rate across the 50 largest metros climbed to 7.6% in 2025, up from 7.2% a year earlier, pushing 44 markets into either renter‑friendly or balanced territory and leaving just six where landlords still clearly “call the shots.”

The same report shows that the national median asking rent fell 1.5% year-over-year in January to $1,672, marking the 29th consecutive month of annual declines and a cumulative 4.8% drop from peak levels, even as rents remain 15.2% higher than they were six years ago.

Twenty-two of the top 50 markets are now classified as renter‑friendly with vacancy above 7%, another 22 are balanced with vacancy between 5% and 7% and only six remain landlord‑friendly with vacancy below 5%. The supply wave that many had anticipated in the wake of pandemic‑era construction is now evident in the numbers, with Realtor.com’s economists pointing to a broad, if uneven, move toward equilibrium rather than a simple one‑directional downturn.

The result is a landscape where cap rate expectations, rent‑growth pro formas and concession strategies are being tested simultaneously in high‑growth Sun Belt markets, maturing Midwest metros and entrenched coastal hubs.

Milwaukee’s whiplash and the rise of high‑vacancy metros

Milwaukee is the clearest example of how quickly conditions can flip. Once a tight‑supply, landlord‑leaning market, the city’s vacancy rate more than doubled in a single year, jumping from 4.9% in 2024 to 10.8% in 2025 and moving the metro firmly into renter‑friendly territory.

Even with that surge in available units, the median asking rent in Milwaukee is still up 1.2% year‑over‑year to $1,630, suggesting the market is in the early stages of repricing and that landlords’ responses via concessions or rate cuts may lag the headline vacancy figures.

Milwaukee is part of a broader cluster of markets where Realtor.com’s data shows high vacancy and clear renter leverage. Birmingham’s vacancy remains elevated at 14.3%, with median rent down 4.7% year‑over‑year to $1,147. Austin’s vacancy rose from 8.2% to 13.8% in 2025, while asking rents fell 7.3% to $1,358, reflecting a market where new supply has run well ahead of demand.

In Detroit, the vacancy rate increased from 8.6% to 9.6%, while rents slipped 3.4% to $1,284. These dynamics highlight how some Sun Belt and Midwest metros that previously captured growth capital are now granting tenants significant negotiating room.

Dallas–Fort Worth and Houston also fit this pattern. Dallas–Fort Worth’s vacancy moved from 8.9% to 10.5%, while asking rents fell 2.5% to $1,410. Houston’s vacancy climbed from 9.8% to 11.4% with a 2.3% rent decline to $1,345.

In Orlando and Tampa, where investors have often priced in durable Sun Belt inflows, vacancy remains renter‑friendly, ranging between 9% and 11.4%, respectively, with rents down 2% in Orlando to $1,640 and down 2.7% in Tampa to $1,667.

Need a Lease Agreement?

Access 150+ state-specific legal landlord forms, including a lease.

 

Unit size, pricing pressure and the rent ladder

The report also shows that the current adjustment varies by unit size, with the middle of the rent ladder carrying a meaningful share of the pressure. Nationally, studios posted a median rent of $1,393 in January, down 1.2% year‑over‑year, with 29 consecutive months of declines and a 5.8% slide from peak levels, though still 10.1% higher than six years ago.

One‑bedroom units recorded a median rent of $1,552, down 1.4% year‑over‑year, with 32 straight months of declines, a 6.3% drop from peak and a 13.4% gain over six years.

Two‑bedroom units are seeing the steepest current pullback. Median rent for two‑bedroom units stands at $1,847, down 1.7% year‑over‑year and 5.7% from peak, even as six‑year growth remains 17%.

That pattern suggests that mid‑sized units, where many households trade up from studios and one‑bedrooms, are absorbing significant discounting, especially in markets with new supply concentrated in mid‑market and upper‑mid‑market product.

Realtor.com’s metro‑level data also highlights how vacancy and rents do not always move in lockstep. In Kansas City, vacancy remains renter‑friendly, easing only slightly from 9.2% to 8.9%, yet median asking rent is up 2.4% year‑over‑year to $1,388.

In Virginia Beach, vacancy eased from 9.1% to 7.5%. While still renter‑friendly, asking rents climbed 4% to $1,624. These cases show that local demand drivers and supply timing can sustain rent growth even where headline vacancy suggests tenants should have the upper hand.

Markets tightening against the national grain

Even as the national narrative leans toward a renter advantage, the Realtor flags a subset of metros moving in the other direction. Pittsburgh and Richmond—both relatively affordable, job‑rich markets—shifted from renter‑friendly to balanced conditions as vacancy compressed. In Pittsburgh, vacancy fell from 8.7% to 6.9% and the median rent ticked up 0.9% to $1,427, a shift likely attributed to a surge in out‑of‑market demand from renters leaving more expensive cities.

Richmond’s vacancy rate dropped from 8.2% to 5.2%, with asking rents rising 1.9% to $1,509, pushing the market into the balanced category and underscoring how quickly “value” locations can absorb excess capacity.

Portland shows a different kind of pivot but remains central to Realtor.com’s story about renter leverage. The metro’s vacancy rose from 5.7% to 7.4%, moving from balanced to renter‑friendly, while asking rents fell 2.3% to $1,627.

Denver, by contrast, moved from landlord‑friendly to balanced as vacancy rose from 4.7% to 6.5%, with median rent declining 4.9% to $ 1,729.

Sacramento followed a similar trajectory, shifting from landlord‑friendly to balanced as vacancy climbed from 3.8% to 6.9% and rents fell 2.3% to $1,818. These metros illustrate how quickly classifications can change and how dependent the durability of renter‑friendly conditions is on continued supply growth.

Some markets are tightening even as they remain, on paper, relatively advantageous for tenants. Indianapolis’ vacancy fell from 9.1% to 6.6%, moving it from renter‑friendly to balanced, while median asking rents dipped only by 0.1% to $1,277.

Columbus shifted from renter‑friendly to balanced as vacancy fell from 7.3% to 5.7%, with rents up 0.3% to $1,187.

Coastal holdouts and landlord‑friendly enclaves

Despite the broader tilt toward renters, the report identifies a small group of coastal hubs that remain landlord‑friendly. This is headlined by Boston, with vacancy remaining low, inching from 3% to 3.2%. And while the median asking rent dropped 2.6% to $2,851 —it’s still high in absolute terms despite the modest decline.

New York’s vacancy edged down from 4.7% to 4.6% and asking rents rose 0.8% to $2,882, underscoring persistent supply constraints in that region.

San Jose, with a vacancy rate of 3.5%, saw rents increase 1.9% to $3,319, the highest median among the tracked metros.

Providence and Riverside round out the landlord‑friendly group. Providence’s vacancy increased only slightly from 3.1% to 3.7%, while median rents fell 3.1% to $1,967. In Riverside, the vacancy rate slipped from 3.7% to 3.3%, with asking rents down 2.7% to $2,067.

Los Angeles, though still landlord‑leaning with a 4.4% vacancy rate, saw a 1.9% decline in rents to $2,730, while San Diego, now classified as balanced with a 5.8% vacancy rate, recorded a 4.6% rent decline to $2,639. These markets show that even in places where landlords retain leverage, rent trajectories are no longer uniformly upward and may be sensitive to incremental supply.

Washington, D.C., features prominently in the report as a case study in transition. The region moved from landlord‑friendly to balanced as vacancy rose from 4.7% to 6.3%, while asking rents still edged up 0.4% to $2,253.

San Francisco remains balanced, with vacancy dipping from 6.4% to 6% and rents up 0.4% to $2,785, suggesting that supply‑constrained coastal markets can see nominal rent growth even as classification metrics normalize.

Methodology and implications for investors

The January report also introduces a methodological change that matters for anyone benchmarking current numbers against older series. Because of this shift, the report cautions that rental data released since February 2026 is not directly comparable with previous releases or earlier economics blog posts.

For investors, that caveat means recent vacancy and rent‑trend figures from Realtor may need to be recalibrated against internal benchmarks and alternative data sources, even as the directional story is hard to ignore.

With only six of the 50 largest metros still clearly tilted toward landlords and 44 now classified as renter‑friendly or balanced, Realtor frames a new baseline for multifamily and rental‑housing investment: a market where tenants have more options and more bargaining power than at any point in the past several years.

Source: GlobeSt.